Most creamy peanut butter lovers, it seems, aren't as open-minded. Process for 1-2 additional minutes: Continue processing the butter until it becomes completely smooth. Want to read more from HuffPost Taste? Brain has sad thoughts Why would you want some sharp, unwanted interlopers like chopped-up peanuts in there spoiling your good times? Smooth peanut butter is… smooth. Peanut butter is a relatively unprocessed food that … Friends, citizens, compatriots, thank you for being here. Chunky or smooth? Next, combine the butter, peanut butter, brown sugar and vanilla extract in the bowl of an electric mixer. Smooth brain looks nice. I've made them hundreds of times, from different recipes, they're a go-to rainy day kind of thing. And neither does peanut butter. While both types of peanut butter each contain a significant dose of protein, creamy peanut butter has just a tad more than its crunchy counterpart. Crinkly crunchy peanut butter brain: crinkly ew. It's a critical debate and you owe it to yourself and your country to participate. Added oils Crunchy peanut butter represents the wholesome values that our lunch sandwiches were built on. If using natural peanut butter (either homemade or peanut butter that is made with just peanuts and salt), be sure any excess oil is stirred in and peanut butter is thick. Smooth vs. chunky peanut butter: It's an age-old debate that never ceases to rev our engines and inspire heated arguments. I'm making cookies for a dog, following the recipe below. Between smooth and crunchy there's again no difference. Even though recipes often specify creamy or chunky, I have always just used whatever I have on hand. We moved to a suburb that has a rendering plant and tannery by the river. They also state that Americans spend almost $800 million on peanut butter each year and that 90 percent of households in the USA consume peanut butter. It calls for natural peanut butter and, of course, i grabbed the chunky. Picture the things you use peanut butter for: A PBJ sandwich. So smooth, in fact, that it’s basically a liquid. (Or at least, the folks responding to a survey about peanut butter do.) The smell makes everyone else think of death, but when I catch that smell on the wind, it makes me think of dried gobs of peanut butter. 1. share. For maximum mouth-stopping, throat-closing, peanut butter textural wham, it has to be smooth. I also dearly love to spread peanut butter on apples. I believe that crunchy textural diversity is an American value. With 90 percent of households consuming peanut butter in the U.S., it's clear that peanut butter really is about as American as apple pie. However, there is always a debate regarding which type of peanut butter is best: creamy or chunky? Recipes and more delivered to your inbox. To make crunchy peanut butter, they start with smooth peanut butter, then add in chunks of real crushed peanuts. Report Save. 7. Picthx Cooking Whims Or the completely-verified, completely-scientific fact that creamy is … Smooth Peanut Butter. At the end of … Though our grocery shelves are packed with myriad options when it comes to peanut butter, there is only one clear choice that provides the textural pleasure, the natural crunch, the satisfyingly toothsome vision our country needs at lunchtime. So what kind of peanut butter do Americans prefer? The question is, does peanut butter go bad? Texture. As a result of the high oil content, peanut butter has much less water, a key factor in the growth of bacteria and fungi. Lincoln-Douglas. level 1. Chunky peanut butter has just enough smoothness and just enough texture, to make it a perfect eating experience. Both are beautiful. Kate Bernot is an impressive beer judge, exemplary coworker, and all-around standup human being. Though I do prefer this Austrian peanut butter. Chunks of real peanuts are in there help to break up the monotony. Creamy peanut butter is a smooth and spreadable high-protein snack. Not the chunky peanut butter though. I would be careful using a natural peanut butter that you need to stir the oil in, it might not work (but I haven't tested it with it). And yet, here we stand, on opposite sides of the crunchy/smooth divide. That Goober stuff was sooo good as a child now, not so much. Part of HuffPost Food & Drink. Jif leads the way in terms of peanut butter sales. I started finding butter knives chunked with peanut butter festering on countertops. This time it was a fight for damages caused when a convict got a jar of Chunky Peanut Butter (instead of two) and one smooth. When it comes to the debate of chunky vs smooth… 1. share. Share. 1. share. A good rule of thumb for choosing a healthy peanut butter is to look for one with the fewest ingredients. Chunky peanut butter smooth gun. Homemade peanut butter will still be a little more gritty than Skippy peanut butter but should be spreadable at this point. According to the National Peanut Board, every year Americans spend almost $800 million on peanut butter. The National Peanut Board states that a full 60 percent of Americans prefer smooth to chunky. Follow us on Twitter, Facebook, Pinterest and Tumblr. Voluntters could not agree on whether it … Musician Charlie Daniels likes the chunky stuff: Just had a banana and crunchy peanut butter sandwich. No Austrian peanut butter pictured here I’m not really a fan. Today we’re going to clear all that up once and for all.This wide, wide world of peanut butters gets confusing mainly because there are so many options. Now, Bernot-Ihnat. 7 months ago. For what purpose, except for messing everything up? It doesn’t come out of the jar on a spoon in the perfect, round mound in which creamy PB does. level 2. Creamy PB is as smooth as a baby’s bottom and is the shade of warm Hawaiian sand. We at HuffPost Taste have to admit we side with the majority. Friends, citizens, compatriots, thank you for being here. Chunky peanut butter, on the other hand, contains slightly more fiber, more saturated fat, and a little bit more folate than smooth. Taste and add more salt or other add-ins to taste. Kate Bernot is a freelance writer and a certified beer judge. It's a rare occasion, however, that we would choose chunky over smooth. When it comes to baking with peanut butter, there’s always a lot of discussion over which peanut butter is best. Oh, let’s make this velvety delicious peanut butter sauce—what’s that? When I moved in with my now-wife in 2002, I found she doesn’t respect countertops. Peanut butter is a staple food that is extremely delectable and is perfect either paired with just about anything or even on its own. Crunchy peanut butter also contains less saturated fat, which is the less healthy fat that your body can take. At least on Twitter, people feel quite strongly that smooth is superior to chunky: My mom just said that my attitude is going to put me in jail one dayLiterally all I asked for was smooth peanut butter instead of crunchy. (You know you're guilty, too.) But when crunchy texture adds pleasure, such as when you pair a PB with a fine apricot preserve in sandwich made with crusty country bread: then I think chunky comes into its own." Fortunately, Kate and I do agree on the real hard-hitting issues: the sacrilege of dunking cookies in milk and the majesty of raw cookie dough. Report Save. It Reminds You That You’re Eating Nuts. Creamy peanut butter contains a bit more Vitamin E and protein than chunky. Is natural chunky peanut butter, vs smooth, ok for a dog? Still, we acknowledge there is a time and place for chunky peanut butter, and we're not alone. We have enough smooth and creamy sandwich spreads these days: jelly, butter, hazelnut spreads, the suddenly trendy smooshed avocados. Peanut butter: I used regular smooth peanut butter. I used to dig smooth. Chunky peanut butter for President. And that, my fellow Americans, is crunchy peanut butter. If it is thin, this recipe wont work well. We at HuffPost Taste have to admit we side with the majority. I have a batch in the works right now, as a matter of fact. You’ve got some gunked-up peanuts in there? Wacky Lawsuits happen often. Our venerable Takeout writers square off to share their impassioned views on one of the greatest culinary issues of our time: Which texture of peanut butter reigns supreme? The National Peanut Board also claims that women opt for smooth, while men lean toward chunky. And that’s okay. Smooth peanut butter eaters self-reported as being more introverted, while crunchy peanut butter eaters tend to be more extroverted. Creamy peanut butter has a touch more protein, but crunchy PB has more folate and fiber, a nutrient that helps maintain bowel health. Smooth peanut butter is creamy, which means it spreads easier on bread, and it mixes better into desserts and smoothies. We need a crunchy spread that’s not afraid to stand up to its smooth counterparts and say look, sometimes we need another viewpoint in our pantry. Life is chunky enough; you don’t need obstacles in your peanut butter. Smooth peanut butter is creamy, which means it spreads easier on bread, and it mixes better into desserts and smoothies. The smooth peanut butter sticks too much in your mouth and it literally gets your tongue tired from eating it. I want jiffy whip, Peanut Butter and apple schnapps as a … Report Save. The National Peanut Board claims that 60 percent of Americans prefer smooth over chunky and that women opt for smooth, while men lean towards chunky. As major peanut butter fans here at HuffPost Taste, we think it's important to keep the debate alive and active, to encourage new voices and opinions on the matter and to stimulate intelligent and thoughtful conversation on what we believe is a matter of national, and indeed global, significance. And Michael Bloomberg once told the New York Post that his last meal would be a chunky peanut butter sandwich... with bacon, no less. Lovely, creamy, probably on soft white bread. Do you prefer smooth or chunky? Instead, it’s a gross runny and lumpy blob. Begin by whisking together the dry ingredients. What we need is a balance, folks. Crunchy PB, on the other hand, is a bumpy brown mess. It’s not too much of a difference nutritionally, but it is still there. Smooth peanut butter also lends itself to being licked from a spoon. The texture makes smooth peanut butter much easier to spread on bread. The answer to this can be found in the composition of the peanut butter. Has no bad thoughts or any at all. Natural or regular? Before hydrogenation in the 1920s, all peanut butter was crunchy. I found the best texture was with 1 cup of Skippy Natural. Interestingly enough, creamy peanut butter contains higher … How to make Chunky peanut butter cookies. I haven't tried it with chunky peanut butter but I think in the cake it would work fine. Well my fellow peanut butter connoisseurs, our arguments can be laid to rest. And that's no mistake. Not to mention the fact chunky peanut butter is super anti-social and terrible at mixers. The best recipes, kitchen tips and genius food facts. Chunky on PB&J and smooth on bananas or apples or celery. Although peanut butter is considered to be a kids’ food, adults actually eat more peanut butter than kids each year. This is nearly impossible to do with chunky peanut butter. Beat until smooth … Picture your perfect PB&J… soft white bread, gooey flavorful jelly, and… SMOOTH or CRUNCHY peanut butter?! Jif Peanut Butter. Most tasters found the texture of 365 Organic Creamy Peanut Butter ($4.39 for 18 oz.) I disagree with Kate on few things, but mainly her desire to put things into things. Smooth peanut butter also lends itself to being licked from a spoon. Though our grocery shelves are packed with myriad options when it comes to peanut butter, there is only one clear choice that provides the textural pleasure, the natural crunch, the satisfyingly toothsome vision our country needs at lunchtime. She was previously managing editor at The Takeout. For peanut butter cookies it's just a matter of taste, and it's 1:1. So where do you stand? We love peanut butter. Whether you call it smooth or creamy, the kind without the chunks is the chosen favorite among Americans. ©2021 BuzzFeed, Inc. All rights reserved. — Scott Mowbray, Editor "Oh, I'm all for chunky. Smooth peanut butter is commonly used in recipes for meals and snacks. That smell of rancid peanut butter ruined it. Owning chunky peanut butter should be illegal, Guys I try so hard to like chunky peanut butter but I just can't, — Kellen Moss (@kellenmoss) July 14, 2014, I CAN'T DATE SOMEONE THAT LIKES CHUNKY PEANUT BUTTER LIKE ID RATHER CUT MU TOES OFF. That’s the common-sense middle ground you’ll get with crunchy peanut butter: not too nutty, not too creamy, just a little bit of chew in each bite. Honestly, probably. Commercial manufacturers have access to industrial-strength machines to get that velvety texture, which can make homemade peanut butter seem grainy and dry in comparison. And may God bless America. We're consuming more than a billion pounds of the stuff each year. Seriously if you prefer crunchy peanut butter over regular I can only assume you are a communist and support socialist economic practices. The key ingredient in peanut butter is the peanut oil that prevents it from going bad for quite some time. I can't do it anymore. But after being raised on smooth peanut butter, I find absolutely no use for the chunky version in today’s modern world, despite my opponent’s, um, friend’s fancy talk about hydrogenation history. The peanuts in smooth peanut butter are ground uniformly, creating a creamy texture. Some bites have more peanuts bits, some have fewer. Won’t you join us? But for years now, peanut butter has been ruined for me. However, once ground down smooth or chunky into peanut butter, particularly if you nosh or the natural nut butter, this popular spread contains plenty of vitamins, minerals, amino acids, and antioxidants to boot. The National Peanut Board also claims that women opt for smooth, while men lean toward chunky. Let us know what your favorite is and why in the comments. Club. I always said if I had one breakfast to eat before I die, it would be Wonder Bread toasted, with Skippy Super Chunky melted on it, slices of overripe banana and fresh crisp bacon. If you, too, are in favor of textural diversity and common-sense deliciousness, please choose chunky peanut butter on your next shopping trip. As far as minerals go, peanut butter is a rich source of calcium, iron, zinc, selenium, manganese, copper, and potassium. Of the 515 people who answered the call, 94% of you rated it 6 out of 10 or higher. So from a strict nutrition perspective, crunchy has a so-slight-it's-insignificant edge over smooth — but only if you favour processed peanut butter, in which case you should switch to the natural stuff anyway, because it's an indisputably healthier choice. Almond butter may also be substituted for the peanut butter. Kennedy-Nixon. When it … The two main types of peanut butter are crunchy (or chunky) and smooth (or creamy).In crunchy peanut butter, some coarsely-ground peanut fragments are included to give extra texture. Original Poster 7 months ago. to be "a bit sticky," extra soft, smooth, and creamy. Gwen Ihnat is the Editorial Coordinator for The A.V. We promise rhetorical skill, cunning wordplay, and dazzling argumentative maneuvers, all in service of the peanut buttery truth. Does this chunky peanut butter hatred stem from the fact that I had braces as a kid and had to stringently avoid it? Chocolate chip cookies don’t need chopped-up nuts.